RIAA To Do The Right Thing?

Fortune reports on the RIAA’s stunning new anti-infringement strategy of suing actual infringers:

“The RIAA is considering a far riskier strategy–suing individuals who share large numbers of files on Kazaa, Grokster, or Morpheus. It’s a tactic guaranteed to infuriate and alienate music fans, and it underscores the awful bind record labels are in.”

Assuming the RIAA chooses to go after folks who clearly and consistently infringe copyrights, music fans should applaud. I certainly will. I have no problem with punishing copyright infringers. What I do object to is laws and litigation aimed at legitimate activities and tools, just because some infringers use them. Punish the infringer, not the tool.

If the RIAA is indeed in an awful bind – if suing blatant infringers is indeed controversial – that is because the public is starting to question the legitimacy of copyright. How can that legitimacy be restored? Punishing the actual bad guys would be a good start.


Comments

One response to “RIAA To Do The Right Thing?”

  1. Interesting to see this perspective from 2002. I remember when the file-sharing wars were really heating up, and the “punish the infringer, not the tool” argument struck me as the most sensible middle ground. It’s a shame the industry took so long to embrace that approach—and that when they finally did, they went after a few high-profile individuals in a way that felt less about justice and more about making examples. The point about restoring copyright’s legitimacy by targeting actual bad actors rather than the technology itself is spot on. If the RIAA had started with that strategy and been transparent about it, maybe we’d have had a more constructive conversation about fair use and compensation rather than a decade of lawsuits and bad PR.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *